by Peter Birnie

Part three in a five-part series on the local music scene

METRO VANCOUVER — People who try to present live music in Vancouver are tired of singing the blues. The Town Pump and Starfish Room and Marine Club are long gone, and Richard’s on Richards is still in the process of morphing into something in the old A&B Sound space on Seymour.

“There’s always been a venue problem for as long as I can remember in this city,” says former city councillor Jim Green. “It’s so difficult because some of the great venues have been neglected or misused, the York Theatre or the Pantages, so there’s the Railway, the Yale and then it starts getting pretty thin for live music.”

Green could add the Media Club and, thankfully, some green shoots indicating new life in Vancouver’s eternal search for places where the seeds of new sounds and bands can be planted. The Rickshaw Theatre is a new space in an old place on Main, while on Kingsway the Biltmore Cabaret has become a welcome home for many bands.

“I was a booking agent for many years, booking national tours,” says the Biltmore’s Aaron Schubert, “and I always had trouble in Vancouver finding decent venues.”
Draconian liquor licensing regulations and an increasingly crowded city centre where not-in-my-backyard noise complaints from nearby condo dwellers can shut a club down stand in the way of a thriving live music scene. Green recalls arriving at city hall in 2002 and learning it was illegal to have amplified live sound or dancing in restaurants.

“It was ludicrous,” he says, “because you could play a jukebox or CDs, or have a DJ, but nothing for live music, which is completely opposite of how things work if you want to develop your cultural sector and make Vancouver the vibrant city that it claims to be.”

In fact, Green has fallen in love with the Biltmore’s Sunday afternoon rockabilly jams.

“It’s a great thing,” he enthuses, “because people can get together to enjoy themselves, and of course on a Sunday afternoon the Biltmore would probably be closed, so it works for everyone.”

Schubert works hard to make his 350-seat room a focal point for live music.

“When I got here my big goal was to try and give us a brand and a type of look that people are going to be attracted to, something different,” he says. “We want to be a music venue where people look forward to coming here and feel like, ‘Wow, we had an amazing night at the Biltmore.’”

Schubert’s optimism about the future for “live” venues — “It was rough there for a while, but right now I believe we are in better shape than we have been in years” — is fuelled in part by an interesting observation.

“The reason the music scene here is on its way to doing well is because, over the last several years, there were a bunch of illegal venues that were incubating the scene. The Emergency Room was responsible for a lot of the indie rock scene in Vancouver right now, that was a room where people knew there was going to be a great party and a great show, and the Sweat Shop — it wasn’t fancy by any means, but you knew you were going to get good local music.”
Where are they now?

“The cops threw the book at ’em,” says Schubert.

Coun. Heather Deal has been struggling with red tape to try to help new venues deal with liquor licences as well as noise and nuisance bylaws.

“I just think that there’s so much energy in the music community here,” says Deal. “They’re looking for places to play and our challenge is finding affordable places that are safe and are managing the noise issues. If we can’t make it possible for them to operate legally then yes, they do tend to go underground.”

And that’s a slippery slope, Deal adds.

“My primary concern is human safety. I don’t think we need to control people’s behaviour too much; we need to control the impact on others, but mostly it’s the safety issue — one of the challenges has been that many of the affordable buildings in town are our oldest buildings, and they have both safety and sound challenges.”

Just ask David Duprey at the Rickshaw Theatre, which went through extensive renovations before opening its doors a couple of months ago at 254 East Hastings.

“I find empty spaces around Vancouver, mostly on the Downtown Eastside,” says Duprey. “I stumbled on this place and tracked down the owner in Hong Kong — 100 years old, one of the Shaw brothers.”
While other new venues such as, well, Venue (in what was the Plaza on Granville), or whatever “Richard’s on Seymour” ends up being called, are going to mix live acts with DJs, the Rickshaw is sticking to a strict live-music-only policy. The place is so big (capacity 700) that Duprey has been able to serve liquor up in the balcony while the main floor of what was once a movie house can remain all-ages, a vital factor in attracting young audiences.

“The city allowed us that for now,” he says. “Everybody on city staff, and all the way up to council, acknowledges that there’s a problem with liquor licensing and how it’s strangling things like live music, and so a lot of people are trying to deal with that — we may be part of an experiment, considering us as a project to see how things could possibly work.”

At the nearby Cobalt Hotel, rock promoter Wendy13 is facing eviction.

“That is a really important punk place,” says Deal, “and I don’t think there’s anything we can do to help her, because that’s between her and her landlord.”

“I don’t know if we’d be able to fill the gap,” says Duprey. “We’ll try, of course, but I don’t know if we’re the right fit for that, which is a drag because those people are going to need somewhere to go.”

Duprey has gone to great lengths to try to placate neighbours — “This place has been closed since 1984, so it’s quite a shock to go from zero to 60” — but remains pessimistic about the potential for more live-music venues.

“The whole not-in-my-backyard thing is really prevalent here in Vancouver, and council’s scared to piss anybody off,” he says. “Hey, I don’t want to live next to a nightclub, but when you live in a densely packed city like this, there are going to be nightclubs in high-density areas.”

Read the original story at https://vancouversun.com/news/part-three-view-on-vancouvers-live-music-venues